Case Study 1

D.G. Biddle & Associates Complete Website Redesign
– Date: 2022
Overview
D.G. Biddle & Associates are an engineering consulting firm.  Their website needed a redesign with a focus on the website information architecture (IA). The navigation made it hard for the user to find information and content was missing.  The client felt that they looked unprofessional compared to their competitors. They needed a website that would showcase their talents and projects.

My Contributions
My role in the project was to undertake UX/UI design of the new website.

The old website to be redesigned.

The Challenge
Was to organize all the content that the client wanted to have in the website.  They needed a navigation system (IA) that would present their content in a logical and meaningful way for the user.
Approach
I used the Double Diamond approach to the design process.
DISCOVER
DEFINE
DESIGN
DELIVER

Stakeholder Interveiw
Heuristic Evaluation
Competitive Analysis
Comparative Analysis

Open Card Sorts
Tree Tests
Data Analysis
Proposed Site Map

Design Studio
Mid-Fi Wireframes
Mid-Fi Prototype
Usability Testing

High-Fi Wireframes
High-Fi Prototype
Usability Testing
Stakeholder Presentation

Double Diamond
Research
After interviewing the stakeholders and researching their competitors.  I start to analyze all the information provided by stakeholders. This includes marketing details, their own research about the industry and business goals. It was discovered developers and contractors are the main users of the website.

A heuristic evaluation of the existing site revealed several structural flaws, specifically: 1) the site’s current IA made locating information and content difficult and confusing, and 2) the site’s overall visual hierarchy had typographical irregularities and lacked brand logic.
Because of the existing site’s disorganization, I conducted open card sort sessions with stakeholders in order to gain insight into how they perceived the firm viewed their website, looking for patterns I could use to inform a new site IA.

After synthesizing the card sort results, I tree-tested two proposed IA’s with two user groups (new users & supers users) to evaluate their intuitiveness. Both tests consisted of 5 users, and I adjusted the second tree test’s IA to reflect insights gained from the first.

It was difficult to organize all the fields of engineering services the client offered. We finally decided on two main categories: Land Development and Building Development. To best illustrate the tree test results, I crafted a new site map, eliminating and shortening several of the existing primary navigation categories.

Site Map

Design
Guided by the new site map, I started sketching my ideas on paper before creating digital versions of them. Since, the redesign is mobile-first, I first worked on the mobile version of the site. Bootstrap was used as the framework.

Wireframes

Testing
Testing the hi-fi prototype with the user group, I found users were successfully able to complete the test’s tasks: 1) find the Land Use Planning page, 2) find the Mechanical Engineering page, 3) find Michael Fry's bio page.

The Verdict Overall, users rated the prototype’s ease of use as 8 out of 10, and their satisfaction level as 8 out of 10.

Throughout testing, users commented on how creative and useful the site is. These results validated our assumptions that the site was both appealing and useful.
Final Design
Below is the final design of the homepage, desktop and mobile. The website contains 20 pages. If you would like to the visit the website, Click Here.

Final Design
www.dgbiddle.com

Results
The website navigation is now laid out in a more logical manner, users are now able to easily navigate the site and findability increased by 80%. Since the website has a responsive design, users can use their mobile devises to view the website. The client is pleased with the redesign.

“Mark led us through the process of this project making a quality website for us.”
- Dave Biddle
Takeaway
I really enjoyed the design process of this case study. Also, thinking outside the box can lead to great ideas.